God knows I am not the biggest fan of ‘Wicked,’ but I really cannot escape it. I hear the songs everywhere, and I do have bragging rights of having seen it with the Original Cast – Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth. So why not, it’s Halloween and NBC has a special, /A Very Wicked Haloween’ which celebrates its 15th Anniversary. I mean, you cannot doubt its success, for sure. And it’s still going strong – with sold out audiences all over the world.
This special, though, is a real mixed bag. It’s a real definition of all over the map. Menzel and Chenoweth host it, and they both look good in their white and green outfits, and it is sure nice to see them together. Both their solos, ‘Popular,’ and ‘Defying Gravity,’ were show stoppers. But the rest of the numbers kind of made me cringe. I didn’t really get the Adam Lambert/Ledisi duet of ‘As Long As You’re Mine,’ and I think I am allergic to anything Pentatonix. The much-hyped Ariana Grande number was okay, I guess, but too much pop melisma for me – but then again that defines this musical. And for ‘For Good,’ which is my favorite song from the musical. it was a nice idea to bring in all the Elphabas and Galindas through the years, but the number was haphazardly presented, with no stage direction at all, and felt messy.
But I am just being a bitchy show queen. I am glad this special exists, and hope they do more of the same.
You can just guess where the state of my emotions are right now because when Idina Menzel sing the track ‘Every Time We Say Goodbye/I’ll Be Seeing You’ from her new album ‘idina:live,’ I started weeping. It’s mostly from a mixture of emotions – some tough breaks lately, missing some departed loved ones, and basically just feeling the gorgeousness of these two songs. I mean, this is not even the most imaginative medlette pairing, but something about it just got to me, and for a brief moment there all those emotions rolled up into that one track.
I wish the rest of the album stirred just as strong emotions. This is a live album from her concert tour last year, and I saw it here in Los Angeles at The Forum, a little before I realized I was moving here. In the album, Menzel is in mixed voice, but I think it is still a wonder. I know people go hot or cold over her, and I get it, as the brass in her voice could be a little too much. But I like it, and it’s unmistakably her own – you hear one note and you know i’s her. I also like the mixed repertoire here – songs from her album ‘idina,’ and songs from stage and screen mostly associated with her. I give credit to someone who can make me listen to ‘No Day But Today; without wincing. The usual Idina standards: “Let It Go,’ ‘Defying gravity,’ ‘I’m Not Your Girl’ are all great to listen to. I remember loving the concert just fine, and she certainly knows how to hold the audience in the palm of her hands (she has star quality to the wazoo) and that chemistry with the crowd translates well in this live album. A weird personal anecdote: it looks like this recording was from the Las Vegas leg of her tour, and I was just thinking if I still lived there, I would probably have gone to this performance….
I have never been to The Greek Theater before, so it was great that on the start of Easter weekend, I saw Idina Menzel live there as the opening act for their 2017 concert season. Sure, the weather was still too cold for an outdoor concert, but is there anything better than seeing one of your favorite divas under the light of he moon and stars? I didn’t think so.
And she was in fine form – her voice, which could sometimes be abrasive, was fine and muted, and she was extremely comfortable on that stage – confident, assured, charming. Maybe it’s her frame of mind – she seems to be enjoying her state of engaged bliss (to actor Aaron Lohr) and she knows she has an audience who is in awe. I know that this tour in is support of her new album (titled Idina.) and even though I had mixed feelings about the album in the beginning, I really warmed up to it after repeated listenings. Now, after seeing her sings these songs in concert, I have become obsessed with the album. As a matter of fact, I listened to it on repeat on my way back from Los Angeles.
She started her show by singing her single form the album, ‘Queen Of Swords.’ I had predicted to a friend that she was going to open her concert with that song, and sure enough, there she is playing bongo drums with it. She followed with ‘Small World,’ and then, finally, to the delight of her Rentheads, ‘Seasons Of Love.’ She gave a good mix of the album’s songs, and her signature ones, seamlessly blending her techno-flavored ‘Wind Beneath My Wings’ with ‘Defying Gravity.’ Even though I disliked the arrangement of the first song, in this context this was a winner. But what shone most about her tonight was her personality – she had the audience at the palm of her hands with her stories, inserting Streisand anecdotes in the middle of ‘Don’t Rain On My Parade’ by singing ‘The Way We Were.’ You got to know a little bit of the real Idina, or at least the scripted Idina that she wants you to know. I walked away from the night loving her more, if that is even possible. As she closed with a wistful ‘Everytime We Say Goodbye,’ I was left wanting for more, just as seasoned performers want you to feel.
After watching ‘Beaches’ the other night, I went on an Idina Menzel kick, listening to her latest album, ‘idina.’ I don’t think I have written about this album since it came out last year, although I certainly have listened to it a lot. Like really, a whole lot.
It would have been easy for Menzel to coast. Every girl and her mother have been singing ‘Let It Go,’ that song from Frozen sung by her, and she could have easily done a covers album of shout songs and people would have bought it by the boatloads. But, and thank God, Menzel has more artistic instincts, and released a pop album of all new songs co-composed by her. I must say it is a pretty brave mood and I think I saw an interview of hers last year with her saying ‘You are either going to love this album or not.’
While I would have loved an album of her singing show music, I kind of dig this album as well. On first listen, one song blended with the next one as if one, but I found a trick to best listen to this album – by putting the album in random status, so each spin becomes a different experience. I love most of these songs, which sound very personal. I love ‘Show me,’ which is about trusting someone after being burned by a love, and her ‘Queen Of Swords’ could be an Ariana grande song but of course Menzel infuses experience and maturity in it that would never be matched by the pony-tailed teen. Listen to the heartbreak in ‘Perfect Story.’ That can only be sung by a woman with world and life experience. Menzel fits and sings it perfectly. My favorite song here is ‘I See You’ where Menzel sings earth mother like, summoning all the broken-hearteds of the world. I hear you, Idina.
This also takes me to the soundtrack to ‘Beaches,’ where Menzel sings five songs. Let’s take ‘Wind Beneath My Wings.’ They wisely tried to get away from Midler’s version, and we get a synth arrangement here that, unfortunately, does not serve the song. In fact, I kind of hate it, as it sounds like it is trying hard to be ‘modern.’ She fares better in ‘The Glory of Love,’ which has a more traditional arrangement, and we can see her voice soar higher here. She covers the Pretender’s ‘I’ll Stand By You’ as well, and while it’s fine, I feel like I have heard her version before. ‘LAst Time’ is a cut from her ‘idina.’ album above, and the song fits a moment in the story perfectly. But my favorite track from the soundtrack is ‘I Can Hear the Music’ which I know from my dear beloved Peggy Lee. I guess thats’ just the kind of guy I am.
A lot of people are asking – does the world really need a ‘beaches’ remake? It’s such a beloved movie for so many people that it would be impossible to top it. Admittedly, it’s a pretty flawed movie, but it has connected with the audience, and to this day people still watch it with a good cry. Even Idina Menzel, who stars in the remake, in an interview with Andy Cohen on ‘Watch What Happens live,’ has said that a lot of older gay men were getting mad at her for doing this role (presumably these are all Bette Midler fans ) but like it or not, here it comes!
So is it any good? Well, it’s not bad, but it pales in scale from the original. The story seems rushed, but I like the update details they did. And I think the CC character needs to be bigger than life, and Menzel seems more everyday woman than diva. Nia Long is great in her role, as the ‘lesser’ character, and Long and Menzel have great easy chemistry that it is easy to believe that their characters are truly best friends. And they use Menzel’s singing voice to good use, although I could imagine it’s not everyone’s cup of tea.
but really, it isn’t that bad. Menzel and Long engage you, and I was pretty touched by the end. It’s impossible to compare it to the original, but for what it is – a Lifetime movie – it serves its purpose, and well.